This was an odd play that felt a bit unoriginal, but it was entertaining nonetheless. A youth group minister, "Rev Kat" (it's possible she's given herself this endearing nickname since her reputation with the congregants seems to be fraught), dedicates herself to the mission of engaging young people at the church. The structure of the play casts the audience as congregants in the church, engaging us in periodic call-and-response. Rev Kat, played by Hannah Cabell, is at once eager to share her love of God as a mentor-friend and also bitter at her position in the church since in her view, she has been relegated to lead youth group because she is a woman.
Rev Kat is single and soon finds herself pining for the newly zealous and surprisingly wise (but only 18-year-old) Chris, played by Cole Doman. The two have amazing chemistry, but the plot of the thing feels a little overdone. The name of the church, the town in NJ, and the last names of the teens have all been "redacted" - perhaps implying that this story somehow ends up in court. The show is lopsided, focusing mostly on the evolving relationship between Kat and Chris. The other teens in the program grapple with eating disorders and other social insecurities, but we don't get too much insight or character development.
There are many allusions and allegories woven throughout the play, some of which were likely lost on me since I'm less familiar with the New Testament. The scenes when the cast portrays famous biblical scenes/artwork display the tension between Kat and Chris beautifully; the scenes feel enlightened, and at the same time elicit discomfort at the sexuality being layered on to these religious moments. The ending is confusing and depressing - we briefly see Kat pregnant. She has ensnared Chris into an adult relationship and he laments aloud that he misses his mom.

