
After his phenomenal Tony-winning show A Strange Loop, we had high expectations for whatever Michael R. Jackson would do next. And while White Girl in Danger has some fantastically catchy and clever songs, the 3+ hour production does not seem quite ready for prime time. The premise is amazing. Jackson grew up watching and loving the classic soap operas that featured all-white main characters, and so he sets the musical in a town called Allwhite where the storylines center on the white characters and the Blackground characters are relegated to janitors and lunch ladies. But what happens when one of the Blackgrounds wants her own Allwhite storyline? All hell breaks loose.
The first half of the show is very very good, but it starts to deteriorate just before intermission and then devolves into chaos in the second act. Jackson does an excellent job of poking fun at classic soap opera tropes (with many references that only soap opera buffs, myself excluded, will get) and highlighting the problematic aspects of racial representation not only in soaps, but also more broadly. Unfortunately, it was hard to hear and process the tightly packed lyrics; something seemed off with the sound in the theater and the actors' voices bounced around the space, creating a cacophony that mirrored the outrageous plot twists on stage.
Even though Keesha Gibbs (played by Latoya Edwards) is the Blackground character yearning for an Allwhite storyline, the surprise main character is her mother, Nell Gibbs (played by Tarra Conner Jones). This twist smartly breaks Nell out of a stereotypical "Mammy" role; unfortunately, her voice is too piercingly shrill and made me cringe during her many songs. The best talent on stage came from the backup trio inspired by Little Shop of Horrors - in particular Jennifer Fouché as Abilene. And Molly Hager stands out as Megan White (in a trio of Allwhite high school girls that also includes Meagan Whitehall and Meagan Whitehead) - we especially enjoyed the lesbian song/sex scene that comes out of nowhere towards the end.
What we didn't enjoy at all was the long monologue at the end delivered by Clarence (one of the Blackground characters, played by James Jackson Jr), but obviously speaking as Jackson. It's as if Jackson did an interview about his inspiration and intention for the musical and then for some reason decided to include the whole explanation in the actual show. Cut the scene and save the exposition for a talkback after the show.
