

After reading subpar reviews when the show was Off-Broadway at The Public, I didn't run to see Suffs when it transferred to Broadway. But I'm a big fan of Shaina Taub, and after the show won Tonys for Best Score and Best Book, I wondered how a musical can win both of those Tonys and somehow miss out on Best Musical. In a disappointing year for new musicals on Broadway, this one shines brightly and probably should have won - it's a cruel and ironic fate for a show with an all-women cast about suffragists to lose to a mostly-men show about gangs (even though I didn't see The Outsiders, I feel like Hillary Clinton was robbed again).
Suffs went through a lot of revisions between its run, as most shows do. But it's unusual for a show to make such an amazing turnaround. The songs are all catchy with clever lyrics, the story is tight, and the whole things runs smoothly from start to finish. Taub gives a strong performance as Alice Paul (she really is doing it all, or as I like to say, Lin Manuel-Miranda-ing, but Taub is a much better vocalist - and there is no reason to compare this show to Hamilton other than that it's about American history). Other standouts include Jenn Colella as Carrie Chapman Catt, Nikki M. James as Ida B. Wells, Ally Bonino as Lucy Burns, and Grace McLean as President Woodrow Wilson.
This ensemble cast of amazing performers portraying awe-inspiring women carries us through a frustrating and unbelievable slice of America's history - one that is still poignantly relevant today as we totter on the edge of democracy. And even with the victory for the suffragists, the show ends with Alice Paul starting the fight for the Equal Rights Amendment. She would roll in her grave to see the country today.
Music Box Theatre
