
Give a Broadway star an inch, and she'll take a mile. After her previous successes, it's no wonder that Idina Menzel can easily sell out a Broadway theater during previews. And if this show stays open for any period of time, it'll be because of her popularity from other roles - not this one.
The show is overly sentimental with a plot that barely holds. A year after her son dies, Jesse suddenly can't take it anymore. After another fight with her wife, she leaves and drives as far away from NYC as possible - west to the Redwoods. There, Jesse stumbles upon 2 people working on collecting samples from the top of the Redwood trees. She convinces them to let her climb with them, and eventually to let her sleep on the platform among the trees. Jesse's fixation that she needs this cathartic experience takes form after she watches a YouTube video of Julia Butterfly Hill's experience living on a platform in the Redwoods to protest deforestation efforts. (Don't worry, we get to watch the YouTube video during the show!)
The cast learned to climb for the show, enlisting the choreographer from Bandaloop. Idina even attempts some dance moves - but her skills are rudimentary at best and the result is more gimmicky than an organic addition to the direction of the show. The most effective moment is when she begins climbing the first time - the video of the Redwood forest on giant screens bordering the stage (with a giant fake tree in the center) pans vertically, creating an immersive illusion that we're moving up to the top of the canopy. I appreciated and enjoyed this effect, but it could also be nauseating and there probably should have been a warning for any audience members with vertigo.
Okay so the plot is thin, the set is underwhelming, the direction is lacking... at least Idina can sing, right? She's a natural powerhouse and shines brightly in an ensemble cast (Rent), or even as a co-lead (Wicked). But when Idina is at the center and the songs are written specifically for her, every song is at an 11. Even sitting in the rear mezzanine, one can get whiplash from the power she brings to every. single. song. The best reprieve from the onslaught was when Khaila Wilcoxon (Becca) gets her own song.
Nederlander Theatre
