
This show is the tourism industry's wet dream. Various scenes take place at all the landmarks: the original Penn Station, the main concourse at Grand Central Terminal, Central Park, Times Square, the Brooklyn Bridge... c'mon, we all know no one leaves their neighborhood. It even sets up entire scenes for the sole purpose of recreating famous New York photographs - though, I'm not complaining about the tap dance scene on construction beams, during lunch, miles above the city.
The music is fine. The song everyone is waiting for ends the show. As the orchestra pit rises up to stage level, the actors step forward to join them and the audience preemptively leans forward too (triggering a cascade of blocked views) and cheers, drowning out the opening notes. Where is the talented ensemble for a dance scene suited to this grand finale? The stage space is empty and unused - in fact the ensemble is notably missing from the second act. Why hire all those dancers and not utilize them properly?
Most of the songs are from John Kander and Fred Ebb's reject pile (with a few new additions by Lin Manuel Miranda), and you can kind of tell. The only other notable song is "But the World Goes 'Round," which Anna Uzele (as Francine Evans) sings beautifully. Unfortunately, her counterpart, Colton Ryan (as Jimmy Doyle), does not impress - not least because the two have zero chemistry. But the real issue in this show lies with the convoluted mess of a lack of a plot. There is little to no character development for the main couple, and even less for the myriad of side characters. The pacing is off and we jump from main story to side story with little transition or connection or resolution; references to World War II tragedies and racial discrimination in the country feel mechanical and compulsory.
But people will see this show. It's a real money-maker, and I hope it helps to fund better shows at other theaters.
