

We had low expectations for this one. Despite knowing that we would like the music, shows that try to create an original story from existing songs are always hit or miss. Alanis Morrisette's Jagged Little Pill album is the epitome of 90s angst. Teenage angst is timeless, and the creators did a good job of using the songs (some more well known than others, and a few brand new ones) to tell a story about a dysfunctional family trying to figure things out.
The Performers
This was an ensemble cast, and everyone is solid. Because many of the roles are teenagers, there are a number of impressive Broadway debuts on display. And the acting is much better than what I've come to expect from new musicals - in particular, Elizabeth Stanley, as Mary Jane Healy, is fantastic as a picture-perfect mom who descends into opioid addiction. You can hear her channeling Alanis when she sings. The other main standout voice is Lauren Patten as Jo, and she gets some of the best songs too, including "You Oughta Know" - which she delivers with enough passion to bring audience members to their feet mid-show. I also really enjoyed Kathryn Gallagher as Bella, and her performance of "Predator" (one of the new songs) is memorable enough to compete with the classics.
The Songs
All of the good ones are in there, and some vaguely familiar ones too. I would argue that a couple of the new songs are better than the lesser known Alanis originals from the early naughts.
The Set
And here is the main negative. More and more musicals rely on screens for scenery, but this show might take the cake. Not only are there a ton of screens, but the projections on the screens - from the facade of a house to a hallway in the school to a shelf of books - are just a bit blurry for some reason. The screens are also on wheels. Everything is on wheels. Each scene is made up of at least 6 screens and 1 piece of furniture. It felt like a rotating Raymour & Flanagan's clearance sale. The cast is constantly wheeling screens and desks and chairs and couches and kitchen islands on and off the stage. And not just for transitions between scenes either. During almost every scene, the main actors are spun around endlessly by the rest of the cast.
The Choreography and The Direction
There are a few really enjoyable dance scenes, including one step routine that is expertly executed. And many of the ensemble dancers get great solo time, though much of the movement is centered on rearranging furniture. Otherwise, there are a couple of great moments in direction - one that stands out is a scene that unfolds backwards, illustrating Mary Jane's opioid fugue.
The Story
The beginning feels a little like the creators were using some kind of checklist to ensure they hit all the social justice issues of contemporary times. The sexually frustrated dad, the opioid-addicted mom, the bisexual adopted daughter, the perfect Harvard-bound son, the lesbian friend, the new kid with a terminally ill sibling, and the slut. It's a lot. But the story does eventually find it's footing and we get to know Mary Jane and her family more than expected
.
