
A musical based loosely on Alicia Key's life growing up in Manhattan, with new arrangements of her songs and a couple of new ones - what could go wrong? Almost everything. We expected a weak plot, but we also expected amazing choreography and music. Unfortunately, the new arrangements are actively bad and the dance scenes were so chaotic that I actually found myself trying to look away each time. Maleah Joi Moon has an amazing voice and does her best as Ali; Shoshana Bean, as Jersey (Ali's mom) has a strong voice that needed less amplification.
The plot is overly simplistic and full of holes. Ali is a teenager eager to be treated like an adult, and the main conflict centers on her relationship with Knuck, an older guy who she approaches on the street. Eventually Jersey asks her cop friends to scare Knuck so he stops coming around, but Ali finds him - her persistent pursual of Knuck borders on stalking. Ali's father, Davis (Brandon Victor Dixon) is MIA - he abandoned Jersey and Ali, prioritizing his piano career over his family - but he's also readily available when Jersey reaches out for his help with teenager Ali. In the meantime, Ali wanders in on Miss Liza Jane (Kecia Lewis) and feels a strong connection to the instrument. So why is she so petulant about learning to play? And if her father didn't leave until Ali was 7 or 8, why didn't he start teaching her? After he disappoints Ali and Jersey again, why do they welcome him back with open arms when he shows up at Miss Liza Jane's funeral and makes the event about himself?
And just how many different ways can Ali and Jersey hug each other in the last scene? They are reconciled. We get it.
Newman Theater at The Public
