
Josh Gad and Andrew Rannells are very funny, and they're very funny playing Bud and Doug in this show. Bud and Doug take a few minutes at the beginning of the show to explain what's going on: they have spent every last penny renting the theater in the hopes of securing a producer for their musical, "Gutenberg! The Musical!" Unfortunately for us, that show isn't very good: the plot is nonsense, the songs are actively bad, and any historical reference is... wrong. We do get a disclaimer that the duo did a couple of Google searches and there is "scant" information on Gutenberg's life and story, but with carte blanche to make it all up, the result is disappointing.
Since this performance is a bid for investment, there are no costumes or sets yet - only trucker hats labeled with the different characters. Bud and Doug don the hats expertly as they switch characters to perform the scenes of the show (even the big dance numbers). This low-budget approach is clever but wears thin by the end. Really the whole conceit wears thin pretty fast and as the second act starts you might wonder... how much more of this is there?
The show is at it's best when Bud and Doug are talking to the audience, dance transitioning across the stage, explaining the standard structure of a musical, or telling stories about their audience at the nursing home where they work. In fact, I think the show should have taken place at the nursing home, with Bud and Doug practicing for this investor performance but enmeshed in their daily lives. Give us more of Bud and Doug, and at the same time give them the talent to put together a show that actually deserves a producer's investment (and our money too).
James Earl Jones Theatre
