
We attended on the first night of previews, and the energy in the theater was palpable. The line to get into the theater was also around the entire block, making the show begin about 20 minutes late. But I'm sure subsequent nights have gone more smoothly. As expected, Chuck Schumer showed up to pump his fist and bask in the applause of Broadway fans. The show itself is entertaining, but the plot is weak and Caroline is a surprisingly unlikeable character.
The Story
This musical revival tells the story of a Black woman working for an affluent Jewish family in Louisiana. (The family feels very "New York," and at no point is there any explanation as to how or why they live in Louisiana.) A recent widower, the father is awkward and distant. The son, Noah, misses his mom and has an unrequited fondness for Caroline; he often goes down to the basement to spend time with Caroline while she does laundry. Caroline is already resentful and bitter with 3 children of her own and only begrudgingly talks to Noah.
The crux of the plot revolves around money. Noah is forgetful and leaves change in his pocket. His well-meaning stepmom attempts to teach him a lesson by telling Caroline she can keep any change Noah leaves in his clothes. Noah starts leaving money on purpose. Caroline is conflicted at first, but then succumbs to temptation. For Chanukah, Noah gets a $20 bill from his grandfather. Of course, he leaves it in his pocket (this time by accident) and things get more complicated.
A secondary plot involves a confederate statue in the center of town that goes missing. It's 1963, but the story feels familiar given the many statues that have been taken down or vandalized recently. There is one heated conversation between Noah's step-grandfather (visiting from New York) and Caroline's eldest daughter that relates to this secondary plot - otherwise the meat of the controversy seems to be missing. He wants to empower her and doesn't agree with MLK's nonviolent tactics. But it's a white man's perspective and it's not helpful. The attempted assassination of Ronald Reagan is also a recurring topic of conversation, but again the point seems to be missing.
The Performers
By far the best part of the show is the talent on stage. Sharon D. Clarke, as Caroline, is incredible - she has a powerhouse voice with an amazing range. Clarke is a great actor too, but her character is mean - you want to root for Caroline, but she makes it really difficult. The other show-stoppers are the performers playing inanimate objects: The Radio, The Washing Machine, The Dryer, and The Bus. This unexpected and delightful idea accentuates Caroline's solitary existence and the effect is one of the best parts of the show.
The Songs
The show starts off strong with Caroline singing in the basement and The Radio (Nasia Thomas, Nya, and Harper Miles) making an entrance. All of the songs are enjoyable in the moment, but none of them stick. Many of the songs feature polyphony, with many performers singing different melodies at once or overlapping. In this case (perhaps something that was fixed post-previews), the sound design seemed off and the effect was unpleasant; we were unable to hear the distinct singers and at times it all combined in a cacophony of sound.
The Set
Showing the upstairs and the downstairs at the same time was a great way to highlight the divide between the family above and Caroline working all day below. But again, the best set pieces were the anthropomorphic machines throughout the show. The worst part of the set was the over-the-top entrance from The Moon - not only was The Moon an entirely unnecessary element of the story, but it was also very confusing. And the most dangerous aspect of the set was the sudden (and also completely gratuitous) rainfall towards the end of Act Two - I don't even recall why it was raining. During the curtain call we feared for the actors coming out onto a wet stage
.
