
The best part of Camelot is the music. Of course, this is still the subpar follow-up to Lerner & Loewe's My Fair Lady. But the beautifully played overture sets the tone and the opening scene is striking, with the stage floor covered in a white sheet to evoke a snowy night. But not even a revised book by Aaron Sorkin can make the plot compelling. Especially since he took out all the magic and then somehow made the plot even more nonsensical by creating a romantic past between Arthur and the sorceress Morgan Le Fey (who in this non-magical world is now a scientist).
The saving grace is Phillipa Soo - she sings and acts the part of Guinevere flawlessly and her performance is almost magical enough to save the whole show. Soo brings personality and humor to the role, especially for "Then You May Take Me to the Fair." If only she had more songs! If only she sang all the songs! Andrew Burnap is fine as Arthur, but he really has no chance when compared to Soo. And Jordan Donica (who was an excellent Freddy in My Fair Lady a few years ago) beautifully sings one of the best songs in the show - "If Ever I Would Leave You" - but the rest of his scenes as a skulking Lancelot are underwhelming.
The gratuitously long sword fighting scene was definitely unwarranted - don't they know we're all just counting the minutes between songs? And the chaotic mishmash of intersecting scenes towards the end - Arthur confronting Le Fey, the knights shouting about how they want to pillage again (with the awful song, "Fie on Goodness"), and Guinevere and Lancelot finally sleeping together - does not help either.
Vivian Beaumont Theater
