
It is unusual to see a show that has so few redeeming qualities. From the start it was clear this was not going to be a clever take on the movie from 2000 (à la Tootsie the musical), but rather an unoriginal version of the movie with added original songs that did more harm that good. These were presented side by side with famous tracks from the movie, but those numbers had new arrangements and the performances of them were overly wrought. When the actors delivered famous one-liners from the movie, the effect was cringe-worthy. And the production felt high budget in all the worst ways: a motorcycle bursting across the stage to emphasize a chaotic free-wheeling backstage concert scene, a model airplane dangles down and flies across the stage, new set pieces for almost every scene, giant neon letters lighting up the backdrop.
The movie is an enjoyable romp through an era of sex, drugs, rock and roll, but mostly earns its nostalgic place in our memories for the star-studded cast. Similarly, the best moments in this musical are when Russell Hammond (Chris Wood), William Miller (Casey Likes in his Broadway debut), and Elaine Miller (Anika Larsen) are on stage - preferably without any of the other characters. Larsen, as William's intimidating mother, stands out the most even in her secondary role and even with the daunting task of living up to the fabulous Frances McDormand who plays the role in the movie.
